Content Refresh Checklist

Content Refresh Checklist

Content & Creative
Slate
Mahesh Sundararaman's checklist ends on a 7/30/90 day read, so you know when to judge a refresh and when to leave it alone.
Source
Slate
Tools
Search Console, GA4
Runs
Per page
Cost
Free guide
Last updated
August 7, 2026

What it is.

You confirm intent against the current results page, read 6 to 12 months of traffic and click-through rate, check for cannibalization, update titles and headings, refresh stale facts, strengthen internal links, add schema and extractable answers, review the call to action, then republish with a change log.

Every candidate page gets scored 1 to 5 on business value, decay severity, ranking opportunity, refresh effort, and AI visibility opportunity. The total decides what you touch first.

Review frequency is set by content type: top-of-funnel posts every 6 to 12 months, comparison pages every 3 to 6, glossary entries yearly, and product pages on release. This is Slate's own guide.

What you get.

  • Nine refresh steps in a set order.
  • A five-dimension scoring model on a 1 to 5 scale for choosing pages.
  • Review intervals by content type, from 3 to 6 months for comparison pages up to yearly for glossaries.
  • A 7/30/90 day measurement window with what to look at on each date.
  • A change log habit, so the next person knows what was already tried.
HOW TO USE IT

How to set it up.

1

Pull the pages that lost clicks over the last 6 to 12 months from Search Console, and ignore anything that never had traffic.

2

Score each candidate from 1 to 5 on business value, decay severity, ranking opportunity, effort, and AI visibility opportunity.

3

Check the live results page for your target query before rewriting, since changed intent means a new page.

4

Look for cannibalization first, because two pages splitting one query needs a merge, which is a different job.

5

Update the title, headings, and stale statistics, then add an extractable answer block and FAQ schema.

6

Republish with a dated change log, then read results at 7, 30, and 90 days without touching the page in between.

Use cases

Choose which pages to refresh

Score candidates on the five dimensions and take the top of the list.

Work the steps in order

Follow the nine steps so nothing gets skipped on a busy week.

Check the result on schedule

Read the page again at each of the checklist's review points.

Best for

A library that stopped growing

Publishing more while the existing pages decay is the expensive answer.

Deciding what to leave alone

The scoring model gives you a reason to skip a page that survives a review meeting.

Setting a maintenance rhythm

Review intervals by content type turn refreshing into a calendar entry.

Open the original.

Hosted on Slate, free to open.
Open the Tool

Questions about Content Refresh Checklist

How do I pick what to refresh?
Can I use it on a new page?
Is it neutral?

Questions about Content & Creative

When does a page deserve a refresh instead of a rewrite?
How do you refresh at volume without it taking a quarter?
Strengths
  • The 7/30/90 read tells you when a number is still noise, so you stop judging a refresh after a week.
  • Cannibalization gets checked before rewriting, so you avoid polishing a page that should be merged.
  • Review intervals differ by content type, which is more honest than a blanket quarterly rule.
Limitations
  • Slate's own guide, and Slate sells the platform behind it.
  • The scoring model needs traffic history, so a page published last month has nothing to score.
  • Nine steps per page is slow at volume, so batch by template and reuse the intent research.
Skip this if
  • Skip it if your refresh work already has a checklist and a review date.
Ideal for
  • Content managers
  • SEO leads
  • Stage: Any stage

Want this running without building it yourself?

TripleDart has scaled 300+ tech companies with expert operators and AI workflows behind every play.